A federal judge ruled against the digital database Internet Archive in a copyright infringement lawsuit filed by four major publishers.
Hachette,Korea HarperCollins, John Wiley & Sons, and Penguin Random House sued Internet Archive following the implementation of its National Emergency Library at the start of the COVID-19 pandemic. Prior to COVID, the Internet Archive lent e-books via a "controlled digital lending" system, or CDL: Libraries offer loans of digitized book copies on a one-to-one basis — that means that they circulate the exact number of copies they own. When the emergency library launched, Internet Archive removed all waitlists for books and lent out any amount of copies on a two-week basis.
On its blog, the archive's director of open libraries Chris Freeland wrote that the emergency library was launched due to the sudden closures of libraries and schools. Publishers sued Internet Archive in June 2020, and soon after, the archive shut down the library.
This week, Judge John G. Koeltl of the U.S. District Court in Manhattan decided that Internet Archive produced "derivative" works that required permission from the copyright holders, the Associated Pressreported.
The "nonprofit library" will appeal the decision, Freeland wrote on its blog. "Today’s lower court decision in Hachette v. Internet Archiveis a blow to all libraries and the communities we serve," he wrote.
"We will continue our work as a library," he noted. "This case does not challenge many of the services we provide with digitized books including interlibrary loan, citation linking, access for the print-disabled, text and data mining, purchasing ebooks, and ongoing donation and preservation of books."
"Libraries are more than the customer service departments for corporate database products. For democracy to thrive at global scale, libraries must be able to sustain their historic role in society—owning, preserving, and lending books," said Internet Archive founder Brewster Kahle in a statement. "This ruling is a blow for libraries, readers, and authors and we plan to appeal it."
Topics Books
Trump who? Tech giants join massive effort to uphold Paris Agreement
How to customize your Apple News alerts
Is that 'Hawkeye' baddie the MCU's way into Netflix's Marvel shows?
Twitter Safety adds new rules that ban "private media"
The Year in Tech: 2014 Top Stories
Precious baby tree kangaroo takes first steps in the outside world
5 apps for scheduling Instagram posts on iPhone and Android
Trump tweets about his lawyer possibly cooperating with officials
Boston Celtics vs. Dallas Mavericks 2025 livestream: Watch NBA online
Precious baby tree kangaroo takes first steps in the outside world
Best Presidents' Day deal: Save $44 on Fitbit Charge 6
Unfortunately, you can't hook up with the Doncaster Council
South Korea will use VR to assess whether elderly drivers can get a license
How Apple's iPod video saved 'The Office'
Google 'Ask for me:' AI that calls businesses on your behalf for pricing and availability
Someone made a PowerPoint to prove Lorde and Jack Antonoff are dating and it's...remarkable
Meta, Facebook, Instagram, and the metaverse: super apps suck
Twitter Safety adds new rules that ban "private media"
The Year in Tech: 2014 Top Stories
Apple celebrates 15 years of fighting AIDS with together with (RED)
Remembering Maxine Kumin by Dan PiepenbringThe Morning Roundup for January 21, 2014On the Chinese New Year, the (Fearsome?) Story of the NianWriters Remember Ronald ReaganAn interview with Daniel Menaker, author of the memoir “My Mistake”The Paris Review and WikipediaA Chocolate ConfessionWe’re in the New York Times Sunday Crossword PuzzleOur New Year’s Resolution: Stop Watching So Much Fucking TV by Dan PiepenbringI Hung Out at William Burroughs’s House When I Was NineteenSadie Stein on the Museum of the City of New York’s exhibit “Gilded New York.”The Morning Roundup for January 24, 2014Our Candy Print Makes the Perfect Valentine’s Day GiftJerry McGill: Sun Records artist, Memphis fixture, and “crazy sonuvabitch.”See Our Poetry Editor, Robyn Creswell, at Housing WorksChoose Your Own Erotic Adventure—If You CanAn interview with Daniel Menaker, author of the memoir “My Mistake”Sadie Stein on Disney’s 1935 Silly Symphony “The Cookie Carnival”We’re in the New York Times Sunday Crossword PuzzleI Hung Out at William Burroughs’s House When I Was Nineteen This video celebrates KFC's launch of a chicken sandwich to 'space' Facebook News Feed change cracks down on spam and fake news Pride posters slated for focusing on straight people Lenovo made a camera specifically for YouTube's VR180 format Microsoft squeezed machine learning onto a Raspberry Pi First photos of Waymo's self 2007 gave us the iPhone, and also a lot of pop culture insanity Iranian city reaches 129.2 degrees, setting national and world records People are in mourning that China pulled a cult Netflix show after just 3 episodes 'Rick and Morty' Season 3 finally, finally gets a release date and a new trailer Why a company is recycling old coffee grounds to make bed sheets You can now spend $10,000 on a bikini made of pizza The special meaning behind Tim Cook's iPhone 10th anniversary tweet For some reason, Katy Perry is really craving Australian meat pies iOS 11 beta Easter egg might reveal iPhone 8's wireless charging sound Ransomware has been around for almost 30 years, so why does it feel like it's getting worse? Sony is bringing vinyl back, but the truth is it never went away Japanese airline apologises after it made disabled man crawl up stairs to his flight The key to getting gender equality in the Constitution may be ... memes? iPhone 2020 roundtable: Dissecting the future of Apple's 'one device'